I just ran across this case study in the February 2008 issue of the New Oxford
Review Vol. LXXV, Number 2. What was so intriguing about it was not only the
valiant attempt to document an alleged "clear cut case of demonic possession",
but more importantly to me at least was the scientific qualifications of the
researcher. Richard Gallagher MD is not only a board certified psychiatrist
in private practice in Hawthorne, NY but also is an Associate Professor of
Clinical Psychiatry at New York Medical College and on the faculty of Columbia
University Psychoanalytic Institute as well for a Roman Catholic Seminary. He
was a Phi Beta Kappa graduate of Princeton University magna cum laude in
Classics and was trained in psychiatry at Yale University School of Medicine.
He is the only American psychiatrist to have been a consistent US Delegate to
the International Association of Exorcists. As those of you have read my other
articles know all too well, I am no fan of the Catholic Church and many of its
erroneous manmade doctrines so this recommendation of Dr.Gallagher's findings
should be accepted with all that much more credibility. All that my article
means to do is to point out a modern day case of demonic possession as
revealed by a learned psychiatrist. It does not, however, deem the peculiar
exorcist practices of the Catholic Church to be necessarily valid or the most
acceptable in treating this possession.
Dr.Gallagher is keenly aware of the many fraudulent instances of so-called
demonic possession and clearly distances his case from them. He speaks not
only of people with obvious psychological problems but also as well of some
prominent televangelists who use this concept to bilk their flocks. His case
of a woman, who they call "Julia", however, is one that he describes as
showing "that the devil, however rarely, may indeed attack by possession an
individual". Julia was raised a Roman Catholic and not only had fallen from
the graces of the church but had become an avowed Satanist. She not only
exhibited obvious signs of demonic possession including going into a trance
and speaking with another voice but she also exhibited 'special occult
powers'.
Dr. Gallagher maintained that all the facts presented in this case study were
true and verified by multiple and highly credible individuals. "Julia" went
herself to local clergy complaining that she was being attacked by a demon or
Satan and asked for an exorcism. After being referred to Dr. Gallagher, she
was examined by him and found to be 'logical, intelligent and even engaging at
times' but definitely was not found to be psychotic.
She would go into a trance. As Dr.Gallagher accurately pointed out, mentally
troubled individuals often dissociate and go into such trances, but she
exhibited behavior, which was different. Out of her mouth came threats, taunts
and scatological language. The booming deep voice (unlike her normal voice)
said "she's ours, leave her alone" and they showed contempt for anything
religious or sacred. The voice called the nuns 'whores'. When she awoke from
the trance she did not remember anything of what was said.
Once again, Dr.Gallagher ruled out Dissociative Identity Disorder.
He assembled a team of 4 Catholic priests, a deacon and his wife, and two
nuns. While phone calls were being made to arrange this group, the most
bizarre thing happened. That deep demonic voice of Julia's that came forth
while she is in a trance, actually materialized itself over the phone lines
saying once again "leave her alone, she is ours!" Dr.Gallagher stated,
"Julia's trance presence was clearly associated with paranormal events".
Objects would fly off of shelves exhibiting psychogenesis. She knew things
about the members of the team's personal lives that she could not have
possibly known. She spoke in Latin and Spanish, which she did not know. Her
trance language was crude, insolent and blasphemous. During her trance she
would often levitate six inches off the table and all those present could not
push her body back down.
Dr Gallagher wrote, "any attempt to explain away an activity of Satan or
the Devil in the Gospels is analogous to irrational skepticism about miracles."
He said, "most
argue that cases of demonic possession are outmoded and superstitious and that
these are ideas that the church should now disavow." He was correct that there
are many cases in the Bible of people being demon possessed and these demons
were removed by Jesus and later by his disciples. Once again, I personally do
not believe that such demons have to be removed by an exorcism sanctioned by
the Catholic Church. Scripture says that the name of Jesus is above all other
names (Philippians 2:9) and at hearing it demons tremble (James 2:19). Calling
out the name of Jesus causes demons to flee not sprinkling so called holy
water on them.
Dr. Gallagher concluded:
"Much superstition, exaggeration, fakery, and sheer ignorance have accompanied
the history of both purported miracles and suspected diabolic activity
throughout the life of the Church. The harm to the faith and the harm to
individuals can be great, a truism never more evident than today. Behind these
false traditions, however, as Pascal well grasped, lay the real thing, the
originals from which the Frenchman well knew the counterfeits drew their false
legitimacy. In this and every age, going back to the Gospels themselves, we
refer ultimately to the consistent record of the healing and freeing power of
our Lord Himself, on body and soul, as manifested to the unbiased mind. My
task here has been to provide some guidance in discerning the counterfeit, but
also in acknowledging the very infrequent but legitimate cases of diabolic
activity. Contrary to what secular opinion facilely asserts, an objective
medical view can confidently conclude that assaults by the devil, like genuine
miracles, are rare but exhibit real scientific facts, verifiable to all who
are not afraid to confront the truth."
I agree with Dr.Gallagher's assessment even though I do not necessarily agree
with his solution. I know one thing for certain and that is that God exists
and so does Satan and his demonic hordes. This case proves that without a
shadow of a doubt. Remember that demons flee at the name of Jesus because it
is the name above all names.